The Friendly Toast is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Top 18 Best Grill Mat For your Smoking Area Review in 2022

Mr James Hall
  Dec 7, 2022 6:38 AM

If you're like me and love to grill, there is a definite need for a good grill mat. '

Not only will it protect your grates and prevent you from turning your nice Weber into a burnt toast ocean of death, but the mat will help with the clean-up and make things easier to transport afterward.

Keeping those pesky hot coals off of your deck or patio is also a benefit. 


Overview

best grill mat

Grilling can be messy, but it's worth it.

The best grill mat is a helpful way to make sure your food is grilled evenly and not burned.

Whatever the event or occasion, we have you covered with the best of the best in grilling mats.

Read more:


Top 18 Grill Mats Review

Showing  1 - 10  in  18 results
TOP Choice
1
  • SCORE
    9.0
    FT Score

    FT Score is a Friendly Toast Score from our review team.

  • Brand
    Renook
TOP Choice
2
  • SCORE
    8.8
    FT Score

    FT Score is a Friendly Toast Score from our review team.

  • Brand
    Kona
TOP Choice
3
  • SCORE
    9.6
    FT Score

    FT Score is a Friendly Toast Score from our review team.

  • Brand
    Cuisinart
Most Saving
4
  • SCORE
    9.0
    FT Score

    FT Score is a Friendly Toast Score from our review team.

  • Brand
    YRYM HT
5
  • SCORE
    9.2
    FT Score

    FT Score is a Friendly Toast Score from our review team.

  • Brand
    LOOCH
6
  • SCORE
    8.8
    FT Score

    FT Score is a Friendly Toast Score from our review team.

  • Brand
    AiBOB
7
  • SCORE
    8.4
    FT Score

    FT Score is a Friendly Toast Score from our review team.

  • Brand
    Huigu
8
  • SCORE
    9.0
    FT Score

    FT Score is a Friendly Toast Score from our review team.

  • Brand
    Grillaholics
9
  • SCORE
    9.0
    FT Score

    FT Score is a Friendly Toast Score from our review team.

  • Brand
    homenote
10
  • SCORE
    9.4
    FT Score

    FT Score is a Friendly Toast Score from our review team.

  • Brand
    WIBIMEN

Last update on 2022-12-07 / Affiliate links / Images, Product Titles, and Product Highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API


Buying Guide

Size

You may have heard that you should use a 12-15" grill mat on a smaller grill or a 16-18" grill mat on a larger one. This is not always correct. The longer the mat, the more heat it will absorb. I have yet to find a situation where I have used one of these longer mats and have been disappointed in the results. Avoid the obvious: long, thin mats cannot be used for grilling anything delicate or thin (like fish or vegetables) because they will just slide around and you'll end up with burnt food and charred fingers.

While most mats of this kind are roughly the same size as a grill grate, some can be smaller. Make sure you know what size your grates are before buying.

Material

Grilling mats are made from many different materials, such as silicone, fiberglass, and natural cotton fiber. They all have their benefits and drawbacks. Some mats will be more flexible than others while some may not be able to withstand the heat of a grill. How they react to heat is a major factor in deciding which one you should buy.

Silicone 

(except for silicone infused with fiberglass) is not a good choice for grilling. The reason for this is that silicone is not heat resistant and will melt on contact with the grill, causing a mushy, soggy mess. Fiberglass is a poor choice because it breaks down at temperatures over 300 degrees F. It can develop off-flavors and release toxic fumes (if you're heating directly on it). Grilling mats made from cotton fibers are considered natural grilling mats and tend to be pretty thin while still being functional. I would suggest that you avoid these if you have an average-sized or larger grill since the mat may fall into your food.

Natural Cotton Fibers

Cotton fibers are very thin and are the easiest and most affordable type of grill mat to find. However, the cotton fibers may not be as sturdy as other materials, so some designs of these mats may not support your weight or sit flat on your grill grate. These mats tend to be tiny when compared to others of similar thickness. They are best suited for small grills but will have trouble with large ones.

Fiberglass 

Fiberglass grill mats are usually made from a high-density resin that is reinforced with a high percentage of glass fibers and granulated minerals to provide exceptional heat distribution and durability. They are more resistant to heat than silicone or natural grill mats. This means that they're not going to burn or break down easily like other grilling mats. They are also thick and heavy enough to provide adequate support for food.

Most fiberglass grill mats come with a food-grade silicone coating on the top that is heat resistant up to 500F (260C) degrees, so it will not melt at all when cooking on your grill.

Features

Now let's talk about a few of the unique designs that some of these mats have to offer. I will only list 3 features in this section because there are many more that I could go into. These are the three I feel are the most important to be aware of when choosing a mat that is best for you.

Non-stick Coating 

This is very useful if you have foods that stick to your grates or find yourself constantly scraping burned bits off of your grates. It's also helpful for cleaning up after your dinner has been cooked and you're ready to remove it from the grill.

"Oven Safe" Coating

This is an extra feature that helps to prevent your grill mat from burning. If your mat does burn, it can leave some residue on your grates. This residue will not only hinder the cooking process but can also cause mineral deposits that may damage the grates and make it difficult to clean them properly.

Glossy Coating 

Some of these mats come with a glossy coating, which I have found to be very helpful when cleaning off my grill after cooking. The glossy coating is also good for preventing food from sticking to the surface while you're grilling.

The different types of grill mats available on the market

Grill Mats

These are mats that are suitable for grilling, but they may not be thick enough to provide, adequate support for your food. They can be useful if you're grilling something small or delicate g and bringing your grill with you. You can find these mats in silicone or a combination of silicone and fiberglass (which is what most will suggest). such as vegetables. They're also great if you're planning on doing some camping

Grill Mats made from natural fibers are thin and can accommodate most grills regardless of their size, but the products made from fiberglass usually have more thickness to them. This is good for providing additional support, but not so good for carrying the heat down to your food. 

Fiberglass Grill Mats

Fiberglass grill mats are usually made from a high-density resin that is reinforced with a high percentage of glass fibers and granulated minerals to provide exceptional heat distribution. They are more resistant to heat than silicone or natural grill mats. This means that they're not going to burn or break down easily like other grilling mats. They are also thick and heavy enough to provide adequate support for food.

Most fiberglass grill mats come with a food-grade silicone coating on top that is heat resistant up to 500F (260C) degrees, so it will not melt at all.

Cotton Fibers

Cotton fibers are very thin and are the easiest and most affordable type of grill mat to find. However, the cotton fibers may not be as sturdy as other materials, so some designs of these mats may not support your weight or sit flat on your grill grate. These mats tend to be tiny when compared to others of similar thickness. They are best suited for small grills but will have trouble with large ones.

Price

The price of a grill mat can vary greatly. You can find mats that cost as little as $5, but you can also find some that cost well over $100 or more. For the average consumer, this is not an issue at all. You should plan on spending between $20 and $40 for a reasonable everyday grilling mat, though some of the more expensive mats will have a longer length (additional length = further heat absorption) and may be more suitable for larger grills.

Some sellers on Amazon sell the same product under different brand names, so I suggest using their "Frequently Bought Together" feature to help jump-start your search for the best grill mat.

The benefits of using the best grill mat

There are hundreds of benefits to using the best grill mat on your grill. The most obvious benefit is that it will keep your food from falling through the gaps between the metal grates, which can cause loss of food, but it's also very helpful for cooking pizza and other foods that require a flat surface. 

Your food will also brown more uniformly when using a grill mat as opposed to simply placing it on your hot grate. The heat is able to penetrate through the top of the mat and cook your food evenly all around while keeping hotter temperatures away from delicate or thinner foods.

Grill mats are very easy to clean up after you have finished grilling with them. This is especially true for the mats made from silicone, but even the thicker fiberglass mats can be cleaned up quickly and easily.

Additionally, if you ever need to dispose of your mat, it's not as big of a deal as it would be if you disposed of your grates. They are disposable and can usually go right in with your regular household trash.

Grill mats are very durable and will last you a long time, usually the lifetime of your grill. If they do get torn, they are very inexpensive to replace. You can expect to pay anywhere from $5 to $50 for a replacement depending on what type of design you choose.

Tips on how to clean a grill mat

There may come a time when your grill mat needs a good cleaning. If your food gets stuck to the mat while it's grilling you'll need to clean it before you can use it again, and if you've had it for several years chances are that food has stuck to it at least once or twice. 

To clean your grill mat thoroughly, we recommend using warm water to rinse off all of the residue of food on the surface. Then, place the mat in a large bowl of warm water alongside some dish soap and let it sit for 10 – 15 minutes. After soaking in soapy water, remove your mat and rinse thoroughly with warm water again.

You can also use mild dish soap and a scrubbing pad to clean your grill mat. Be careful not to use any harsh chemicals when cleaning your grill mat, as they will damage it over time.

If your grill mat gets filthy and you're not sure how to get in there and clean it, you can use baby wipes or a damp cloth to wash it off right away. Don't use rubbing alcohol or other harsh chemicals as they will damage the fibers of the mat. This damage is irreversible so be very careful when removing this item from your grill regularly and make sure that you allow it to completely dry before storing it away again.


FAQs

What are grill mats good for?

Grill mats are used in grills around the world, and they're a very popular item. These rubber or felt grill mats are best suited for grilling any type of food on your gas or charcoal grill. There are many kinds of grill mats out there, which you can find here on Amazon.

What is the best type of grill mat?

There is no best grill mat, instead of many different options that vary in thickness, effectiveness, and price. The thickness of the mat will determine how well you can use it and how much it will cost you to purchase. The more expensive the mat is typically thicker and more durable than the cheaper models which are thinner and less durable.

Do you still get grill marks with a grill mat?

Yes, you can still get good grill marks with a grill mat. It will depend on the thickness of the mat. Thin mats will not be able to produce as much of a sear or grill mark, but not all foods require that for a delicious flavor. You can also flip your food during grilling to get some grill marks, too.

What is the best size to buy?

Choosing the right size grill mat will depend on how big your actual grill is and what type of food you're looking to cook on it. Most people prefer using really thin mats for their small grills because they are easy to store in between uses and clean up very easily after each use.

Can Silpat be used on the grill?

Silpat is a type of kitchen mat but it is also very popular among grillers. Silpat mats are usually made from natural rubber on the bottom and are a thin, non-stick surface that can easily be wiped off without getting stained. These grilling mats are most suited for small grills with flat cooking surfaces.


Conclusion

Grill mats can be a great addition to any gas or charcoal grill. Finding the right one for your particular grill size and shape will help you get the best results out of your grilling experience. You can find a wide variety of grill mats on Amazon that vary in thickness, material, and price

 You can even find single or multiple packs if you want to give them a try before committing to a full pack. The best grill mat for you is out there just waiting to be discovered!

Do you have any tips or tricks for using grill mats? What do you find yourself doing during the grilling process to get the best results from your meats, vegetables, or pizza? Let us know by leaving a comment below.


5
1 ratings